Selection of Proppants
Proppant materials are selected based on the following attributes:
- Size: The size of a proppant grain depends on the predicted size of a fracture and the requirements of the equipment used for the hydraulic fracturing job.
- Crush strength: The proppant material must be able to withstand the pressure exerted by the surrounding rocks, otherwise it will be crushed. Tiny fragments of crushed proppant grains can clog up pores, resulting in formation damage. For added expense, proppants can be coated with resin, which prevents fragments of crushed proppants from migrating and causing formation damage.
- Weight: Heavier proppants are more difficult to move through the well and fracture networks. However, they are often stronger. This attribute is usually a trade-off between strength and ease of transport down the wellbore.
- Cost: As always, economic considerations are critical when determining whether a certain proppant is worth the cost. In addition to the cost of the proppants themselves, the increased cost of getting heavier proppants to the fractures (by increasing flow rates or viscosity) needs to be taken into account.
Ceramic Proppant
Resin-Coated Proppant
Sand Proppant
Typical attributes of some common proppants are shown in the table below.
Material | Strength | Crush Strength | Weight |
Sand | Weak | 6,000 PSI | 2.6 |
Kiln Fired Clay | Medium | 10,000 PSI | 2.7 |
Bauxite | Strong | 20,000 PSI | 3.6 |
Citations
1. Bellarby, J., 2009, Well completion design (1st ed.): Boston, Mass; Amsterdam, Netherlands: Elsevier, 726 p.[/toggle]
Images: “Ceramic Proppant” by Top Energy Training; “Resin-coated Proppant” by Top Energy Training; “Sand Proppant” by Top Energy Training